Michael Jackson Said Marvin Gaye Was His Only Real Teacher — Marvin Never Knew Until the Music Spoke D

For Michael Jackson called Marvin Gaye his only real teacher. Marvin never knew. The lesson he taught without knowing it changed pop music forever. A tune it was 1979 and a 20-year-old from Gary, Indiana was sitting in a recording studio in Los Angeles listening to a record that was going to change the direction of everything he had been building toward.

He had been famous since he was 5 years old. He had been performing professionally since he was 8. He had spent the entirety of his childhood and adolescence in the machinery of the music industry. On stages, in studios, in the specific, pressurized, relentless environment of a family act managed by a father whose approach to his children’s talent was comprehensive and unsparing.

He had made hit records. He had performed on television shows. He had been recognized on streets in cities he had never visited before, had signed autographs for people older than his parents. Had been famous in the specific, consuming way that the late 1960s and 1970s had of manufacturing child stardom.

He had done all of this. And he was 20 years old and sitting in a recording studio and listening to a record that was making him understand for the first time with complete clarity that he had not yet made the music he was capable of making. The record was Let’s Get It On by Marvin Gaye. Not because he had not heard it before.

He had heard it many times. It had been everywhere when it was released in 1973, had been on the radio and in the cars and in the homes of everyone he knew. But hearing it at 20, in a recording studio, through speakers that were built for the specific purpose of revealing what was actually in a piece of music rather than providing a pleasant listening experience.

Hearing it like that, he understood something about it that the radio version had not fully transmitted. He understood what Marvin Gaye was doing with his voice. Not technically. Michael Jackson was already one of the most technically gifted vocalists alive at 20, had been studying the mechanics of singing since before he could read, could hear in any given performance the specific choices the singer was making about breath and placement and phrasing and timing.

He had analyzed those things in Marvin’s recordings before and understood them with the precision of someone who had been trained to understand them. What he understood in that studio at 20, through those speakers, was something different. Something that was not in the technical choices, but underneath them.

The quality that made Marvin Gaye’s voice do what it did to people. The thing that was not about range or control or the ability to move between registers, the thing that was not teachable in the way that breath support is teachable or diction is teachable. The willingness to be completely present. Not performing presents, actual presents.

The specific, irreducible quality of a human being who has stopped managing the distance between themselves and the listener and has simply allowed whatever is actually inside them to come through the microphone without the protective layer of professionalism or the management of image or the carefully maintained gap between who the performer is and what the performer is showing the audience.

Michael Jackson had been performing since he was 5 years old. He had learned in those 15 years of performing everything that the industry could teach him about how to be on a stage and in a studio and in front of a camera. He had learned to give an audience what they needed. He had learned to read a room and respond to it, to control the experience of watching him in ways that maximized the impact on the audience.

What he had not learned, what the machinery of child stardom and the Jackson 5 and the Motown system and everything that had made him famous had not taught him, because teaching it was not in the interest of the system, was how to stop performing. Marvin Gaye, in the recordings he had made in the early 1970s, had stopped performing.

Had found, through the battle with Berry Gordy and the 2 years of silence and the throat surgery and the recovery that had forced him to listen differently, a way of being in front of a microphone that was not performance in the conventional sense. That was closer to confession. To the specific, terrifying, ultimately liberating act of saying what was actually true without the protection of the frame that performance provides.

Michael Jackson sat in that studio in 1979 and heard what that sounded like. And he understood that it was the thing he had not yet done. The thing that his voice, which was already extraordinary, already capable of things that most singers could not approach, had not yet been asked to do. He went home and started thinking about what it would mean to do it.

The album that resulted from that thinking was Off the Wall, released in 1979. The album that introduced Michael Jackson, not the child star, not the Jackson 5 member, but Michael Jackson the artist to the world. The album that went quadruple platinum and produced four top 10 singles and that critics who had been treating Michael Jackson as a commercial phenomenon rather than a serious artist suddenly found themselves writing about with the language of genuine respect.

Off the Wall was the album of a young man who had decided to be present. Not completely. He was 20 years old. It was his first attempt at the thing he had seen Marvin Gaye do. And the distance between hearing something in someone else’s work and achieving it in your own requires more than one record. But the attempt was there, audible in the specific quality of his voice on the ballads, in the way he moved between registers not as a technical demonstration, but as an emotional response to what the song was doing.

He did not tell anyone at the time where this had come from. Michael Jackson was not, in 1979 or at any other point in his career, a man who gave away the architecture of his creative process to journalists or interviewers or anyone else who might want to understand it. He was intensely private about the things that mattered most to him, intensely protective of the sources of whatever it was that made his work the way it was.

But in conversations with people he trusted, with his sister Janet, with collaborators who worked with him through the 1980s, with a handful of people who were genuinely close to him in the specific sense of knowing what was going on underneath the performance of Michael Jackson that he presented to the world, he was more direct.

He said, “Marvin taught me.” Not in a classroom, not in the explicit, structured sense of a teacher and a student in a formal relationship. Marvin Gaye taught Michael Jackson the way that the greatest artists always teach. Through the work itself, through the specific, irreplaceable experience of encountering music that shows you what is possible, that reveals to you the gap between where you are and where the art can go, that makes you understand something about what you are trying to do that you could not have understood any other way. Marvin never knew. This is the part of the story that carries a particular weight. Not tragic, not ironic in a simple way, but complex in the way that the best things are complex. Marvin Gaye was alive when Off the Wall was released. He heard it. He knew Michael Jackson. They moved in overlapping worlds, had mutual connections, existed in the same

rarefied space of black American music that produced most of what the world was listening to. He heard Off the Wall and he heard in the specific quality of Michael Jackson’s voice on those recordings something that resonated with what he himself was trying to do. But he did not know that he had been the one to show it to him.

He did not know that a 20-year-old had been sitting in a studio listening to Let’s Get It On through speakers that revealed what was actually in the music and had understood something from it that had changed the direction of what Michael Jackson was going to become. By the time Thriller was released in 1982, the album that would become the best-selling album in the history of recorded music, that would transform Michael Jackson from a very successful artist into a global phenomenon without precedent or comparison. Marvin Gaye was in the middle of his own complicated late period. He was in Ostend, Belgium, making the music that would eventually become Sexual Healing and the Midnight Love album. He was broke, recovering from addiction, uncertain about his future in a way that the the man who had made What’s Going On had probably not anticipated for himself.

He heard Thriller. He was asked, in an interview conducted around the time of its release, about Michael Jackson. He said something that has been quoted in various forms in various accounts of both men’s lives, something that amounts, in all of them, to the same essential statement. He said that Michael Jackson was the most complete performer he had ever seen.

Not the most gifted. Marvin was careful about that distinction. The most complete. The one who had found a way to bring all the elements together. The voice, the physicality, the sense of what an audience needed, and the ability to give it to them. In a package so unified and so fully realized that it was almost impossible to identify the seams between the different components.

He did not know he was describing in part something he had taught. This is how influence actually works most of the time. Not in the clean, documented, acknowledged way that biographies prefer. The mentor and the student, the explicit transmission of knowledge from one generation to the next, the moment where the teacher says, “I taught you this.

” And the student says, “Yes, you did.” But in the messier, more human, more true way of people absorbing from each other in real time, of artists encountering each other’s work and having something happen in them that they cannot fully explain or trace or attribute with precision. Michael Jackson absorbed something from Marvin Gaye that changed what he made.

Marvin Gaye never fully knew that he had given it. And the music that resulted from this invisible exchange, the music that Off the Wall and Thriller and Bad contain, is the music that defined popular music for a generation, that set the standard against which everything that came after in pop and R&B and soul has been measured.

The lesson was not about any specific technical skill. It was not about vocal technique or stage presence or production choices or any of the individual components that the music press tends to focus on when it tries to explain why certain music does what it does to people. The lesson was about permission.

Permission to be completely present in a song. Permission to let the audience hear what was actually happening inside you rather than a carefully managed version of it. Permission to treat the microphone not as an instrument to be performed through, but as a conduit for whatever was real, whatever was honest, whatever was the most true thing you had available to give.

Marvin Gaye had given himself this permission in 1970 in the battle over What’s Going On, in the months of silence and the throat surgery and the recording sessions that produced Let’s Get It On. He had taken it from Berry Gordy in a sense, had demanded it from the system that had been telling him for 9 years what he was allowed to say and how he was allowed to say it and what format his honesty was allowed to take.

He had taken the permission and used it to make the most important music of his career. And then, without knowing it, he had given the same permission to a 20-year-old from Gary, Indiana, who was sitting in a studio in 1979 listening to what that permission sounded like. Michael Jackson took the permission and used it to make the most commercially successful music in the history of popular music.

Not because commercial success was the goal. Michael Jackson was as serious an artist as Marvin Gaye, as committed to the quality and the honesty of what he made as any artist who has ever worked at that level. But because the music that results from genuine presence, from the willingness to be completely honest in front of a microphone, reaches people in a place that managed, protective, performance-oriented music cannot reach.

It reaches the place that Marvin Gaye always went for. The place underneath the conscious processing, underneath the critical faculty, underneath the part of the listener that is evaluating and categorizing and deciding what to think. The place where the music just lands. Where it does something to you before you have had a chance to decide what you think about it.

Marvin Gaye found that place consistently throughout a career that produced some of the most important music the 20th century generated. Michael Jackson found it because he had heard Marvin find it and had understood what finding it required and had been willing to try. The lesson was never formally given.

The gratitude was never formally expressed, at least not in the direct, bilateral way that would have required one man to say to the other, “You changed what I do and I know it.” Michael Jackson died in 2009. Marvin Gaye had died in 1984. The conversation that would have made the lesson explicit never happened.

But the music had the conversation instead. Off the Wall and Let’s Get It On exist in permanent dialogue. Two records made by two different men in two different decades reaching for the same thing from different starting points. Both finding it in ways that the people who heard them recognized as true even when they could not explain why.

This is the conversation that music has when the people who made it are gone. Not the conversation about who influenced whom. Not the critical conversation about originality and debt and the genealogy of style. The deeper conversation. The one about what they were both trying to do and what they understood about what music was for and why the willingness to be completely present in a song is the most important thing a musician can offer the people who are listening.

Marvin Gaye taught Michael Jackson without knowing it. Michael Jackson learned without being able to fully say what he had learned or where it had come from. And the music they each made separately, in different studios, in different decades, with different sounds and different audiences and different everything except the essential thing, is the proof that the lesson was real.

The most important thing one artist can give another is not technique. It is not advice. It is not the explicit transmission of knowledge in a formal relationship between teacher and student. It is the work itself. The specific, irreplaceable example of what is possible when a person stops performing and starts being present.

When the microphone becomes not an instrument to to be played through, but a conduit for whatever is most true, Marvin Gaye gave Michael Jackson that example. And Michael Jackson, who had been performing since he was 5 years old and who understood better than almost anyone what it cost to stop, took it and built something with it that the world has never stopped listening to.

He called Marvin his only real teacher. Marvin never knew. But the music knew. The music always knows. [sighs] If this story moved you, if you felt something hearing about a lesson that was given without being given and received without being fully understood, subscribe and hit that like button.

Share this video with someone who needs to be reminded that the most important things we teach are often the things we teach without knowing we are teaching them. Leave a comment telling us, “What does Marvin Gaye’s music mean to you?” Ring that notification bell so you never miss another story about the legends who changed music forever.

We will see you in the next one.